Thursday, May 28, 2009

Digging a Deeper Hole

Bond traders took a case of the frights yesterday, driving up yields on 10-year Treasury notes and 30-year mortgages. Investors are scared, reports the Wall Street Journal, because the United States government is racking up such enormous quantities of debt.

The government will sell nearly $2 trillion in U.S. Treasury bonds this year to fund its stimulus programs, and investors worry there won't be enough demand for it. Slack demand would send bond prices down and push up the government's cost of raising money.
So, what does this mean to people who don't speculate in interest rate futures? For starters, it means that the interest rate on 30-year mortgages jumped from 5.03% to 5.29%, which will make real estate a bit more expensive to finance, thus depressing housing prices generally.

And what does it portend for the solvency of the U.S. government? What most people don't realize is that, as the world's largest debtor, Uncle Sam has benefited the last 20 years from steadily declining interest rates. Lower interest rates have made it easier to finance the staggering amount of debt the nation has added to its balance sheet. Conversely, higher interest rates will make the ever-escalating debt more difficult to manage.

Eighteen years ago (December 1990), the U.S. debt stood at $3.0 trillion. At the end of 2008, it had almost quadrupled, to $11.2 trillion. Yet interest payments on the national debt had less than doubled, from about $265 billion in 1990 to $451 billion in 2008. How did that happen? In a word, a global surplus of capital cut interest rates in half. The table below compares the interest rates the U.S. paid across the so-called yield curve. (Click on image for a more legible version.)

As you can see, the 10-year and 30-year interest rates at close of business Tuesday (May 26) were less than half of what they were almost two decades ago. The short-term notes are a tiny fraction.

It doesn't take a Ph.D. in economics to forecast what would happen if interest rates rose again to the levels that prevailed only 18 years ago: The debt burden would double, adding an untouchable $450 billion a year in interest payments to the U.S. budget, year after year, forever.

Of course, long-term rates ticked up only one-quarter percent Wednesday. There's a long way before they get back to 8.0%. But significantly higher rates could await us as the governments of the largest economies of the world (not just the U.S., but all major economies) continue their borrowing binges, and as aging populations around the world begin drawing down their savings, thus diminishing the supply of capital instead of adding to it.

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Consumers Still Can't Kick their Debt Habit

Here's the good news: Americans are actively looking for ways to spend less, they're getting more disciplined about borrowing, and more of them are setting side savings for emergencies, concludes a new study, "Debt: The Detour on America's Road to Retirement," published by life insurance company Securian.

Here's the bad news (there's always bad news, isn't there?): For all their good intentions, Americans aren't actually working down their debt. "Overall, the amount of debt reported in the Securian survey has not changed since the 2007 survey," states a press release summary. Except among Baby Boomers. They're in worse shape. Says Securian: "Now one in five of the Boomers who are in debt owe at least $50,000 in non-mortgage debt, compared to about one-tenth in 2007."

The early 21st century is giving birth to a new phenomenon: the debt-addled retiree. Way to go, guys. Let's see how the debt thing works for you while you're living on fixed incomes, you're making minimum payments on your credit cards, and the interest starts consuming you like flesh-eating bacteria!

Reading between the lines of the Securian data, it appears that Americans are curtailing their spending mainly in one area: Buying cars. The number of survey respondants making car payments declined from 57% in late 2007 to 47% now. (E.T., call Detroit.) Otherwise, the percentage of Americans with credit cards, home equity loans and other non-mortgage debts remain about the same. Anyone want to bet that as soon as the economic picture brightens, Americans will stampede back into the auto showrooms?

Securian looks for the silver lining: "While the study shows little evidence that more Americans are paying down their debt, the ability to tread water against the current is encouraging. It appears the recession is teaching Americans a lesson about debt and dealing with personal finances, leaving them optimistic about future improvement in their financial lives."

Exculpatory factoid: The U.S. personal savings rate in the 1st quarter of 2009 did edge up to 4.0% from near zero in 2007 and 2008, so somebody must be saving something. But that's still less than half the traditional U.S. savings rate, and far lower than that of most European nations. For Boomers approaching retirement, time is running out.

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Retire Early -- Get Yours While You Can

Just when I thought things couldn't get any worse... they got worse. Forget the effluvia that pass for headlines coming out of Wall Street and the White House. We track broad social and economic trends here at Boomergeddon, and one key indicator -- the age at which Americans retire -- has turned negative. In the process, the American people proved me naive. Worse, the churlish dogs proved me wrong! How dare they?

Here's the background: One of the few shreds of good cheer that I could extract from the misery of the past year is what seemed to be the changing attitude of the American people. (See my heart-rendingly misguided post of two days ago.) The politicians may be failing us, I thought, but the sturdy stock from the heartland would set things right. Americans had responded in survey after survey that they intended to spend less, pay down debt, save more and work longer before retiring. The evidence pointed to a fundamental shift in values -- a rejection of the something-for-nothing attitude responsible for the mess we're in -- that would outlast the economic downturn.

Now comes the Los Angeles Times with the news that far from delaying retirement, Baby Boomers are retiring earlier than ever! Since the beginning of the fiscal year Oct. 1, Social Security enrollments have been running 25% ahead of last year, compared to the 15% that had been forecast. That alarming data point comes from Stephen C. Goss, chief actuary for the Social Security Administration. (Hat tip to reader Groveton for alerting me to the story.)

As the L.A. Times article dryly notes: "The numbers upend expectations that older Americans who sustained financial losses in the recession would work longer to rebuild their nest eggs. In a December poll sponsored by CareerBuilder, 60% of workers older than 60 said they planned to postpone retirement."

Goss suggests that many of the enrollees are laid-off workers grasping for any source of income they can find. That explanation sounds plausible, and it may well be true. But it may not be the whole story.

Here's what really scares me: What if Boomers are retiring early because they don't trust the system? Dr. Helen Smith raises the possibility in her Dr. Helen blog: "My guess is that anyone close to early retirement figures it's now or never, given the possibility that Social Security benefits will be cut down or dry up in the near future."

The Social Security Administration says it has enough money in the till to last until 2037. But rational people will act on that knowledge only if they believe the retirement safety net won't combust between now and then. We may be witnessing an erosion of confidence on the part of everyday Americans that parallels the increasing disquiet in the financial world with America the Profligate.

Monday, May 25, 2009

Up to the Neck in Debt

Money Magazine publishes a "Best Places to Retire" ranking of American MSAs (Metropolitan Statistical Areas) that factors in such considerations as affordable housing, life expectancy and availability of real estate on the water. I suppose the list will prove useful to someone with a five- or 10-year time horizon but the guidance is suitable only to those who think the future will be like today -- only more so. If you believe, like I do, that the United States faces an age wave apocalypse, you expect the country to experience major discontinuities that will render current retirement nostrums null and void.

If the federal government becomes insolvent, the criteria for "best places to retire" will change drastically. Among other things, people will look for state and local governments that are fiscally sound enough to provide basic government services -- perhaps even to pick up some of the functions that the federal government will be compelled to abandon.

I made much the same point last Thursday, when I asked the question, "Who will pick up the pieces?" The example of California, which is bidding to become the next federal bail-out recipient, does not inspire confidence. To provide readers a gauge of the states' fiscal health, I reproduced a ranking of state bond ratings. But reader Peter Galuszka reminded me that the track record in recent years of the rating agencies, including Standard & Poor's, hardly inspires confidence in their judgment.

Fair enough. The list at right, modified from data compiled by the Tax Foundation (and passed along by alert reader Larry Gross) contains two important data points for each of the 50 states: indebtedness per capita, and state debt as a percentage of the Gross Domestic Product. For purposes of comparison, remember that the per-capita debt of the United States stood at 44% last year and is projected to reach 77% by 2013.

(Click on image for more legible version.)

It is interesting to note that some states with a small-government reputation -- Montana, New Hampshire and South Carolina -- rank high in indebtedness. Texas and Tennessee, by this criterion, are looking golden. Conversely, the debt burden of California, today's poster child of fiscal woe, is slightly lower than the national average. Presumably, the Golden State's troubles have causes other than excessive borrowing. Therefore, be warned: A favorable, low-indebtedness ranking on this list is no guarantee of future solvency.

But it's safe to say this: All other things being equal, states with low levels of indebtedness have more financial flexibility to face the uncertainties of the future than those that are in hock up to their necks. Massachusetts -- more than $10,500 in debt and a debt-to-GDP ratio of 19.8% two years ago -- is not a state that I would count on to provide old-age services a decade or two from now.

Saturday, May 23, 2009

A Little Work Never Hurt Anyone

It's a good thing the American people have more common sense than their political leaders do. If the United States dodges Boomergeddon, the age wave apocalypse, we will have the citizenry to thank, not the panderers in Washington, D.C. Repeated opinion surveys have shown that Americans are changing their expectations about retirement. For the first time in more than 100 years, it's possible that Americans, on average, will start retiring later in life, not earlier. That could ease the excruciating financial pressure on the nation's old-age entitlement programs.

According to "Retirement at the Tipping Point," a report issued by the Age Wave consulting firm, pre-retirees say they will need to postpone their retirement by 4.2 years on average. Baby Boomers, who are closest to retirement, figure on delaying it by 3.6 years, Gen Xers and Millennials (Gen Ys) by as much as five years.

As the table below, taken from the Age Wave study, shows, the trend toward earlier retirement reached a plateau in the 1980s that has remain largely fixed for 25 years. Thanks to longer life expectancies, though, Americans are spending more years in retirement.


If you think about it, the social trends of (a) living longer and (b) retiring earlier are difficult to sustain. The Age Wave study discusses a concept called the "work-to-retirement" ratio, the number of years an average American works expressed as a ratio of the number of years they spend in retirement.

A century ago, when the average retirement age was 74 and life expectancies were far shorter than today, retirements tended to be short. Really short. On average, Americans spent 54 years working for every year they spent in retirement. By 1950 that ratio had improved considerably: On average, Americans spent 6.3 years working for every year they spent in retirement. That ratio has continued to improve, reaching the point in 2005 when Americans spent 2.2 years working for every year in retirement.

Let's express that another way: Americans are spending one third of their adult (post-education) years in retirement.

Americans are now realizing that expectations for so much leisure time are unrealistic. One reason people are having such trouble saving sufficient sums for retirement is that they aren't working long enough. (Remember, much of wealth accumulation comes from the simple power of compound interest.) Similarly, one reason Social Security and Medicare will run out of money is that the number of Americans working and paying into the system will be too small to support the number of retirees drawing benefits.

Many politicians and pundits persist in peddling the fantasy that we can continue expanding our entitlements without bankrupting the country. The American people have more sense: They know they have to work longer. Now, let's see if they actually do.

Postscript: European opinion seems to be going in the wrong direction. Governing elites understand the fiscal dilemma posed by their nations' rich retirement programs, but the people are less than enthusiastic about the idea of delaying retirement. Indeed, a majority of citizens in Spain (67%), Italy (60%), France (57%), Greece (57%) and Austria (54%) say they want to retire earlier, according to a recent French survey. Large minorities in northern Europe want the same thing.

Friday, May 22, 2009

Malls: A Ticking Time Bomb

Here's some more news to brighten your day: An increasing number of malls are going out of business, putting financial pressure on the retailers and mall developers that make a living from them, and creating another headache for the banks that finance them. Besides suffering from a massive hangover from excess borrowing, the U.S. soon will feel the effects of building projects in the wrong locations.

In the 12 months ended March 31, reports the Wall Street Journal, U.S. malls collectively logged a 6.5% decline in tenant same-store sales. That's a direct outgrowth of consumers retrenching from their decades-long binge of mass overconsumption. Retail sales are down not only because consumer credit is tightening but because millions of Americans have awoken to the fact that they carry way too much debt and have saved too little for retirement. It will take years for retail spending to return to 2008 levels.

But the awfulness doesn't stop there. The decline in retail sales is hurting big retailers, prompting Stardard & Poor's to downgrade credit ratings on department store companies like Macy's and Sears. General Growth Properties, a Real Estate Investment Trust owning more than 200 malls, filed for bankrtupcy protection last month. Based on the rule of thumb that malls must generate $250 per square foot or more to survive, the WSJ has concluded that 84 of the 1,032 malls in the Green Street database are in danger of failing.

What the Journal article doesn't explore is the location of those malls. I would hypothesize that the vast majority are located on the development fringe of metropolitan areas -- the farthest outposts of "suburban sprawl" (an imprecise term that I hate using) developed in the era of cheap gasoline, long commutes and massive speculative building of residential real estate. The real estate bubble has burst, however, and the glut of unsold houses is worst in outlying areas. Many developers will find that not only are consumers spending less, but the markets their malls were built to serve will never materialize. Wealth destruction on such a massive scale is a tragedy.

The story gets worse. Malls are extremely difficult to repurpose. Owners will find it difficult to adapt them to an alternate use. And timing is running out. The five-year financing for many developers will expire in a year or two, and developers will have to refinance. It's only a matter of time before we see a slew of developer bankruptcies -- and another massive wave of bad loans reported by banks. It's not clear to me if the Obama administration's bank "stress tests" took the impending tidal wave of commercial real estate defaults, but I wouldn't be surprised if the issue was swept under the rug.

Burt P. Flickinger III with Strategic Resource Group, a research firm, put it this way to the Journal: "The shopper-center bankrtuptcies and the REIT bankruptcies are the ticking time bomb that people aren't talking about."

Sadly, Boomergeddonites, there is more bad economic news, more banking hysteria, and more pressure for government bail-outs to come. The age wave apocalypse may be running ahead of schedule.

(By the way, type in "empty mall" on YouTube, and you'll see dozens of video clips like the one above.)

Britannia Takes a Hit on the Starboard Bow

The financial world is abuzz with the news that Standard & Poor's has issued a warning that the United Kingdom might lose its coveted AAA credit rating. S&P cited the nation's massive budget deficits and the mounting national debt, which could soar from 49% of Gross Domestic Product last year to a projected 97% by 2013. That's quite a comedown for Britannia, whose currency, the pound sterling, once played the same exalted role as the dollar in the world economy.

After briefly fleeing the pound and buying dollars yesterday, reports the Wall Street Journal, some players began worrying that the United States might be next and began deserting the dollar.

"It's the pace of deteriorating in finances that is the driving factor here," said Huw Worthington of Barclay's Capital. "The U.K. and the U.S. have fallen hard and fast." According to the Journal, the U.S. national debt stood at 44% of GDP last year and is forecast to rise to 77% by 2013. S&P reaffirmed its AAA rating for the U.S. but anyone looking at the Obama administration's projections of continued massive deficits in the years ahead has to wonder how long.

What it means to the average Joe. The bond-rating news is important to more than bond traders, currency speculators and other members of the electronic herd, as Thomas Friedman dubbed the fickle, fleet-footed money managers who shift capital around the world with a click of computer mouse. A lower credit rating will translate directly into higher interest rates , which will add that much more to the strain of carrying a massive national debt.

The finances of every major industrialized country are deteriorating -- that happens during recessions. Unlike past recessions, no one's fooling themselves that anyone will return to a balanced budget: Any improvement in the economy will be offset by increasing obligations for old-age and retirement benefits.

When a single nation runs up big deficits, it has little impact on global capital markets. When every major nation runs chronic deficits and piles up national debt, governments will begin "crowding out" businesses and consumers in the quest for capital. Interest rates will rise, and that will hinder the economic recovery. Debtors will suffer, and cash will be king.

(Photo credit of the HMS Britannia, sunk by a German U-boat in 1918: Battleships-Cruisers.co.uk.)

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Who Will Pick up the Pieces?

While the prospect of financial insolvency is still two or three decades off for the federal government, it's much closer at hand for the state of California. In February, Standard & Poor lowered its rating for the "tarnished gold" state to A -- a notch below that of Louisiana, though still investment grade (just barely). In the aftermath of the referenda earlier this week in which voters summarily dismissed some $16 billion in proposed income, sales and car taxes, the capacity of the state pay its debts is the object of considerable speculation.

California has problems that make it uniquely ungovernable: entrenched liberal special interests that refuse to cut spending, and constitutional restrictions that give small-government conservatives leverage to block tax hikes. Therefore, one should be cautious about extrapolating from the California experience to other states.

But there are implications for those of us who don't live on the Left Coast. First, if the state is threatened with imminent bankruptcy, is there any chance that Congress and/or the Obama administration will seek to bail it out? And if so, would that open the floodgates for other states in weakened financial condition? What new open-ended burden would a bail-out foist upon the federal treasury? And what new moral hazard would we create if states facing painful budget decisions can run to Uncle Sam for relief?

There is another set of questions regarding the longer term outlook. Assuming, as I do, that there is a high probability that the federal government will face a financial crisis within two or three decades that makes the recent unpleasantness in La La Land look like a bounced check by comparison, one might ask: If the federal government becomes insolvent, what backstops are left? What entities will be in a position to continue providing essential government services?

The answer is: the states. Let me be more precise: The fiscally sound states. To get a sense of whom the long-term survivors might be when the age wave apocalypse wreaks its devastation upon the nation, I can think of no better indicator than the state bond rating. Bond ratings are far from infallible, but they are the best measure we have. To the left, I reproduce the S&P bond ratings for the 50 states. To see what Moody's and Fitch have to say, visit my source, Stateline.org.

(Click on the table at left to view a more legible image.)

Boomergeddon survival tip: If you're young enough to live until the age wave apocalypse, you might give some thought to residing in a state with a AAA bond rating. (Between Delaware, Maryland, Virginia and North Carolina, which all have AAA ratings, anywhere in the Mid-Atlantic looks like a good bet.) Personally, I like the idea of living in a place, like my home state of Virginia, where state and local government is still likely to be functioning. Little things like courts and a police force to protect against gangs of armed, post-apocalyptic marauders will give a big boost to the quality of life.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

As Good as Gold. Er, Would You Believe Silver? How about Scrap Metal?

Credible observers have begun to question the strength of the U.S. government's AAA bond rating. Listen to David Walker, former controller general, writing in the Financial Times:

For too long, the US has delayed making the tough but necessary choices needed to reverse its deteriorating financial condition. One could even argue that our government does not deserve a triple A credit rating based on our current financial condition, structural fiscal imbalances and political stalemate. The credit rating agencies have been wildly wrong before, not least with mortgage-backed securities.

How can one justify bestowing a triple A rating on an entity with an accumulated negative net worth of more than $11,000bn ... and additional off-balance sheet obligations of $45,000bn? An entity that is set to run a $1,800bn-plus deficit for the current year and trillion dollar-plus deficits for years to come?

If you're in the same camp as Salon.com columnist Michael Lind, you might not deem Walker, a prominent figure in the "Fiscal Wake-Up Tour," a credible source. Perhaps you think he's part of the right-wing scare machine or the "anti-Social Security" lobby. OK, then, how about Moody's? Back in January, the debt-rating company proclaimed that the US was at risk of losing its top-notch triple-A credit rating within a decade unless it curtailed soaring healthcare and social security spending. (Read the report in Financial Times.)

In a more recent story, Reuters quotes Peter Morici, a professor of international business at the University of Maryland: "The triple-A rating is undeserved. Because the U.S. can print its own money, it won't formally lose its AAA, but in reality, the bonds are as risky as bonds that are below AAA. ... If Washington were a state capital, we would have lost the AAA with the current budget."

I don't know enough to offer an informed judgment on the issue. But when people start waving red flags and the financial media find them credible enough to pay attention, I get worried.

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

New Attitude

A couple of months ago, I was vacationing with my family at the Club Med in Cancun when I got to know an affable Frenchman, Michel, a former school teacher who now was pursuing the good life. He maintained a home in Paris and a pied a terre on the Mediterranean coast, and he took two long (by American standards) vacations every year. He'd visited most of the Club Meds between the Maldives and the Turks & Caicos islands.

Although Michel was about my age, give or take a year, he was retired already. I figure I'll be working full time at least 10 more years, until I'm 66 or 67, and even then, I'll likely work on and off on projects of my choosing. It's my sense that Michel and I are fairly representative of the Baby Boomer generations of our respective countries. We have very different expectations about what retirement means and of the obligation of the state to meet those expectations.

Here in America, the ambition of the Silent Generation (those born between 1926 and 1945) was very much like that of the Europeans -- to retire as early as possible with enough money to travel the world, have a house on the beach, sail boats, play golf or pursue their personal interests. To both the Europeans and the Silent Gens, retirement marked a dramatic life transition: a move from the world of work to the world of leisure.

There is widespread recognition in both Europe and the U.S. that the dream is unaffordable. Yet it has been difficult both here and there to reform the pension and health care systems. Working through their lobby, the AARP, the Silent Gens in the U.S. have stridently opposed efforts to dial back their retirement privileges. Indeed, during the Bush administration, they succeeded in winning an expansion of the Medicare program that will cost trillions of dollars over the next half century.

But the Baby Boomers may be a different story. While Boomers still look to government for Social Security and health care benefits in their old age -- they've paid into the system, by George, and they want to get something out of it -- they aren't dogmatic about retiring early. Boomers, as a generation, have found meaning in life largely through their work. Their identities are tied up in their jobs. Surveys have found that a majority of Boomers see work as a way to stay mentally engaged, remain connected to other people and otherwise retain their vitality.

Boomers are redefining the work/retirement transition from an all-or-nothing proposition to an opportunity to re-set the work-life balance. In a survey conducted by the Age Wave consulting firm, "Retirement at the Tipping Point," only 30% of Boomers said they saw themselves never working again. Forty-three percent said they expected to go back and forth between periods of work and leisure, while 22% said they probably would work part time. Many Boomers fantasize about starting a new business, often based around a personal interest, or about applying their skills for a worthy cause.

This new Boomer attitude is a very good thing. For starters, Boomers have failed miserably as a generation to save for their retirement. They'll need the money. What I find most reassuring, though, is that they aren't looking to the Big Daddy in Washington, D.C. to bail them out. Americans know they screwed up by failing to save. They also suspect that Big Daddy may not be able to afford to maintain Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security at current levels in face of the retirement tsunami.

Boomers will have to save more (which means spending less) and they'll have to work longer, if they want to enjoy a secure and comfortable lifestyle in their old age. When the federal government faces insolvency 20 or 30 years from now, Boomers will have no choice but to fall back upon their own resources. They had better start preparing now. They appear to be doing so.

Monday, May 18, 2009

How Much More Will China Lend Us?

President Obama made a statement a couple of days ago -- "We can't keep on just borrowing from China" -- that got me to thinking. Just how much money have we borrowed from China? And how important a creditor is China in the grand scheme of things?

Well, here are the numbers, courtesy of the U.S. Department of Treasury (in billions of dollars):

As of April 2009, the United States government owed mainland Chinese investors $767.9 billion, and Hong Kong investors $78.9 billion for a total of $846.8 billion.

At that point in time, the total national debt stood at $11,238.6 billion (or $11.2 trillion). The largest holders of U.S. debt were other federal agencies, e.g. Social Security and Medicare. But those two agencies have almost peaked as investors in Treasury bonds. Soon, they will start redeeming their holdings, which currently amount to $4.3 trillion, to offset revenue shortfalls. That process will unwind over the next three decades.

Who, then, will pick up the $1.8 billion in new debt stemming from this year's deficit? We have no choice but to turn to foreigners, who already own roughly half the private (non-U.S. governmental) debt today. For all practical purposes, that means China and Japan, which are by far the largest holders of T-bills. The Europeans, once prominent among buyers of U.S. Treasuries, are relatively insigificant now. Furthermore, European nations, which are running massive deficits of their own, are soaking up a lot of capital, so it's hard to imagine them entering the picture in a big way.

It's an open question how much appetite the Chinese have to incur more U.S. debt. According to Forbes magazine, the country has invested more than half of its $2 trillion worth of currency reserves in U.S. treasury securities and other government bonds. Fears are increasing among many Chinese observers that the U.S. will hose them by printing money, cheapening the value of the dollar and making that investment worth less.

If the Chinese don't step in and buy U.S. debt, who will? Possibly U.S. investors, now that the Americans' savings rate is creeping higher from its near-zero level of a year ago. But if Americans don't pony up the tens of billions required, Treasury may find it necessary to raise interest rates. That's not what our economy needs now -- and it won't exactly help the U.S. debt burden. Interest payments on the debt already exceed $450 billion a year. An up-tick in interest rates will drive that number higher.

Rising indebtedness, skittish foreign investors, climbing interest rates, and escalating interest payments that drive up debt payments and deficits even more... Let us hope that vicious cycle doesn't spiral out of control.

Sunday, May 17, 2009

What Is Wrong with This Picture?

One must wonder: Does President Barack Obama ever experience cognitive dissonance?

Speaking in New Mexico a couple days back, Obama called the United States' deficit spending “unsustainable.” He warned of skyrocketing interest rates if the U.S. continues to finance government by borrowing from other countries, reports Bloomberg.

“We can’t keep on just borrowing from China,” Obama said at a town-hall meeting. “We have to pay interest on that debt, and that means we are mortgaging our children’s future with more and more debt.” Creditors will tire of buying U.S. debt, causing interest rates to rise. "It will have a dampening effect on our economy."

All very true. But who's this "we" he's talking about? Obama's main accomplishment during his brief tenure in office has been to preside over a doubling of the federal budget deficit -- no easy accomplishment considering the garagantuan budget hole that President Bush created in his last year. The Bloomberg article provides details:

Earlier this week, the Obama administration revised its own budget estimates and raised the projected deficit for this year to a record $1.84 trillion, up 5 percent from the February estimate. The revision for the 2010 fiscal year estimated the deficit at $1.26 trillion, up 7.4 percent from the February figure.
But the good news is, having jacked up the deficit estimate by $92 billion since February, Obama's going to whack it back down by $17 billion -- assuming he can get his cuts through Congress. For the benefit of the reader, I have created a pie chart to show the magnitude of those cuts compared to the deficit (the deficit, not total spending).

Here's another way of looking at it. Assuming that $1.84 trillion in debt costs the U.S. about 2% in annual interest (click here to see the yield curve for U.S. treasuries), this one year's deficit will add about $36.8 billion a year to the U.S. budget burden for, oh... forever!

Friday, May 15, 2009

Can the Obama Administration Reform the Unreformable?

President Barack Obama has vowed to put the United States on a sustainable fiscal path, and Peter Orszag, his director of Management and Budget has an idea of how to do it: Bring health care costs under control.

Medicare and Medicaid expenditures, if left to increase unchecked, could increase from 5% of the Gross Domestic Product today to 20% by 2050, he wrote in a Wall Street Journal op-ed yesterday. "Over the long run, the deficit impact of every other fiscal policy variable is swamped by the impact of health-care costs. ... The good news is that there appear to be significant opportunities to reduce health-care costs over time without impairing the quality of care or outcomes."

Health care costs vary widely across different regions of the country, and even between hospitals and physicians within regions, he argues, following the thinking of Princeton health care economist Uwe Reinhardt. Yet there is little difference in the quality of the outcome. Quoting Reinhardt, he writes: "How can it be that the 'best medical care in the world' costs twice as much as 'the best medical care in the world?'"

By moving the nation toward proven best practices adopted by lower-cost areas and hospitals, suggests Orzsag, it may be possible to reduce health care expenditures by 30% -- or about $700 billion a year -- without compromising quality. Even if those efficiencies are achieved over decades, it should be possible to hold the Medicare/Medicaid share of the GDP to only 10% of the economy.

And how does he propose to tame health care?
There are four key steps: 1) health information technology, because we can't improve what we don't measure; 2) more research into what works and what doesn't, so doctors don't recommend treatments that don't improve health; 3) prevention and wellness, so that people do the things that keep them healthy and avoid costs associated with health risks such as smoking and obesity; and 4) changes in financial incentives for providers so that they are incentivized rather than penalized for delivering high-quality care.
In the abstract, there are all excellent ideas. Indeed, they are so excellent that health care analysts have been talking about them for years. The question we must ask is, why haven't they been implemented already? What is it about the political economy of health care in the United States stymies efforts to rationalize the system?

I don't have a complete answer, and if I did, it would be too long for this blog post. But let me suggest that the U.S. health care system is dysfunctional because of the intrusive reach of government at both the federal and state levels. I will just touch upon some of the highlights:
  • De facto price controls. Medicare and Medicaid reimburse hospitals and doctors on the basis of customary and traditional experience, not supply and demand. Moreover, they consistently pay less than the market price. The result is supply shortages in critical areas such as primary care. Primary care physicians are retiring in droves or retreating into lucrative concierge medicine practices, creating acute shortages of the front-line physicians required to provide the "prevention and wellness" that Orszag talks about.

  • Certificates of Public Need (COPN). Many if not most states regulate the ability of health care providers to build new facilities, on the grounds that new facilities add to the cost structure that insurers must reimburse. But COPN protects hospitals from competition -- not only from other hospitals but from surgery centers and other providers that specialize in procedures they can perform more productively and with superior patient outcomes.
  • Health care guilds. Much like a Medieval guild or a 20th century craft union, the health care industry is divided into occupational categories. Each is guarded by professional associations that lobby in state legislatures to set educational standards and protect their prerogatives vis a vis other occupations. The restrictions limit labor flexibility in the health care workplace and is deliterious to productivity.
  • Mandated benefits. The health care professions also lobby state legislators to require insurance carriers to provide certain types of health benefits. Mandates hamper the ability of carriers to provide affordable, bargain-basement health policies, contributing directly to the increase in the number of uninsured Americans.

The Obama administration has some good ideas for controlling runaway health care costs -- especially investing in Information Technology to bring the industry up to national standards. But color me skeptical. Not only will Orsag run into the usual buzz-saw of entrenched special interests and craven politicians in Congress, the Obamoids will find their ideas far more difficult to implement in the marketplace than they can imagine. If "comprehensive" health care reform is limited to the items that Orszag describes, it won't be very comprehensive at all.

Our Fiscal Black Hole Has Competition -- From Europe's Fiscal Black Hole

The United States isn't the only country facing a long-term retirement crisis: The nations of the European Union are staring down a fiscal black hole. Suffering as much from the global downturn as the U.S., European nations are running up spectacular budget deficits of their own. Now Joaquin Almunia, the EU's top economic official, is warning that rising debt will force governments to curtail spending and rethink their pension systems and welfare benefits, reports the Wall Street Journal.

Meanwhile, says the Journal, the International Monetary Fund has declared that European nations must make "a clear and credible commitment to long-run fiscal discipline" or outside investors will start demanding higher interest rates.

Although U.S. budget deficits have outstripped those of European countries in the past two years, we still have some catching up to do when it comes to mortgaging our future. National debt measured as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product approaches 80% in Germany, 120% in Italy and 75% in France -- as gauged by eyeballing a chart in the print version of today's WSJ. (The chart isn't available in the online edition, and I could not locate the IMF statistics that the Journal drew from, so I cannot reproduce it here.) My eyeball reckoning suggests that the U.S. debt burden is about the same as France's and slightly bigger than the United Kingdom's.

This chart from the IMF shows what's happening on a global perspective (public debt as a percentage of GDP):

Here's what worries me. European countries are responding to their looming pension/benefits crisis with modest reforms, but they are tinkering on the margins. A slowing economy is making the situation worse. The European Union, with an economy comparable in size to that of the U.S., is piling up governmental debt as fast as we are. Looking out 10 or 20 years, not only do U.S. deficits threaten to soak up the global pool of investment capital, so do the deficits of EU nations.

It's a big world, and there are lots of savings, much of it coming from developed countries. Maybe there's enough capital to keep feeding the insatiable appetite for U.S. debt. But is there enough capital to feed ever-escalating U.S. and European debt? What happens when the age wave swamps Japan, Korea, China and the other advanced East Asian nations? Can savings from India, Brazil and the petrostates sustain all of the world's wealthiest societies?

I don't know the answer, but I do know it is senseless to look at U.S. fiscal challenges in isolation. As our populations age, our entitlements swell and our national debt mounts, our government will be competing with the governments of other sovereign nations for a finite supply of capital to fund it.

Only a few very Americans have ever heard of Joaquin Almunia. But maybe we ought to heed his advice. I would be very much surprised if the Europeans do.

Thursday, May 14, 2009

The Mighty Quinn

Everybody's in despair, every girl and boy
But when Quinn the Eskimo gets here
Everybody's gonna jump for joy

-- "The Mighty Quinn," by Bob Dylan

James Quinn, a champion of Average Joes who live responsibly and play by the rules, is one of the most formidable writers on the Internet today. His most recent tour de force, "Jesus in Suburbia" combines mesmorizing data, trenchant analysis and a rhetorical style that leaves whiplash scars on its victims. If he hasn't been discovered by the big publishing players yet, it's only a matter of time before he will be. Read his latest essay on his website, The Burning Platform, and tell your friends that you discovered him before he became a household name.

That's not to say that I agree with everything Quinn says -- I find his indictment of an entire generation of Baby Boomers to be a bit indiscriminate -- but his critique of the sociology and political economy of early 21st century America is otherwise dead on.

By Quinn's reckoning, we're all guilty of the mess we're in, although some are more deserving of tar and feathering than others. In "Jesus in Suburbia," he argues that the suburban lifestyle that Americans have created since World War II is financially unsustainable: built upon a quicksand foundation of debt and the Baby Boomer generation's pursuit of material gratification. Much of the illusory prosperity of the past decade was financed not through increased productivity or higher rates of saving but the plundering of equity from the housing market. The chart below, taken from "Jesus of Suburbia," shows how lackluster our economic growth over the past decade would have been without the borrowing.


Here's Quinn's indictment of American materialism:

Our society has chosen to super size our houses, our vehicles, our TVs, our kitchens, our burgers, our sodas, and our egos. ... Even though 1 in 8 homes exceed 3,500 square feet, there still isn’t room for all our stuff.

Americans have accumulated so much stuff that their McMansions can’t contain it all. At year-end 1984 there were 6,601 self storage facilities with 290 million square feet of rentable self storage in the U.S. At year end 2008, there were 51,250 “primary” self storage facilities representing 2.35 billion square feet -- an increase of more than 2.0 billion square feet. There is 7.4 square feet of self storage space for every man, woman and child in the nation; thus, it is physically possible that every American could stand – all at the same time – under the total canopy of self storage roofing.

(To show that great minds thing alike, I made very similar points in a column on my old Bacon's Rebellion web site, including the references to George Carlin's "stuff," excessively large homes to store it in, and the rise of the self storage industry. See "The Excesses of Affluence." My apologies for the ill-maintained condition of the web site, which is now the responsibility of others to maintain.)

Let me close with one more quotation:

The entire suburban existence of the last twenty years has been a fraud, built on a foundation of debt, with bankers lying to investors and homeowners deceiving themselves. ...

We have tripled the size of our houses, and reduced the sense of community in our nation. Many have perfectly manicured lawns, polished appliances, 12 spotless rooms and dysfunctional, aloof, joyless lives. A McMansion, stainless steel appliances, 6 flat screens, and granite countertops do not guarantee happiness. When all of these items are bought on credit, you have a tragedy. America has degenerated into a materialistic, corrupt, me first, soul-less society. Nobody is right. Nobody is wrong. Everyone deserves to win, even if they made horrible decisions. Unless this changes soon, this country is doomed. By 2020 the United States will essentially be an old aged pension fund with an army.

Heed that last sentence: If we learn nothing from our most recent mistakes -- and who, upon reading Quinn can think that we have learned anything? -- we are doomed to repeat our mistakes on an even larger scale in the future. The 2008-2009 bursting of the housing bubble and the melt-down on Wall Street was mere prelude to the Boomergeddon to come.

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Apocalypse Denier

There is no entitlements crisis, writes Salon.com contributor Michael Lind in "Let's cut Social Security to pay for banker bailouts!" It's a scare ginned up by an "anti-Social Security lobby" consisting of "libertarian zealots, Jeffersonian conservatives, center-right Democrats and bankers and brokers who would like to earn fees or commissions from the diversion of Social Security payroll taxes into IRAs."

Lind concedes that health care costs are a legitimate problem, but he manages to sweep that issue under the rug by focusing on the supposed non-problem of Social Security. One point in particular struck me because it had the veneer of plausibility:

The anti-Social Security lobby always presents the "unfunded liabilities" of "entitlements" in scary dollar terms, rather than as percentage points of GDP. Here's why: Over the next 75 years, the Social Security shortfall at most hovers around 1 percent of total U.S. GDP over that same period. Yes, that's right -- around a whopping 1 percent of U.S. GDP. And that is only in the unlikely event that some combination of growth, taxes and benefit cuts do not eliminate the shortfall in the future.
Fair enough. Let's take a closer look at the numbers. The chart below shows total projected entitlement deficits as a percentage of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). I can assure readers that this does not come from libertarian zealots or anyone of that stripe. I took it from the just published "Summary of the 2009 Annual Reports" of the Social Security and Medicare boards of trustees. It was published under the names of four people, including three Obama appointees -- Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, Labor Secretary Hilda Solis, and Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius. Presumably, they are not party to any anti-Social Security cabal.

The blue on the bars represents revenue shortfalls for the Old-Age and Disability and Survivors Insurance (OASDI) trust fund, better known as the Social Security trust fund. Just as Lind says, the deficit never exceeds one percent of the GDP through the year 2083.

Of course, Social Security represents the most actuarially sound part of America's retirement safety net. It's the smallest part of the entitlement crisis. The red in the chart represents the projected revenue shortfall for Medicare Part A, also called HI, which covers payments to hospitals. The deficit in that program is growing rapidly, and will account for nearly 4% of the economy by 2083. That's the funding shortfall, mind you, not the total cost of the program. By way of comparison, the entire U.S. budget deficit in 2004, the bottom of the last business cycle, was 3.53% of GDP.

The green in the chart depicts SMI, or Medicare Parts B and D, which pay for physicians and drugs. Those don't have a trust fund. They generate some revenue from enrollees, but the bulk is paid out of the U.S. general fund. That deficit is roughly equal to the other two programs combined.

But that's not the end of the story. This chart doesn't touch upon the ramped up Medicaid expenditures we can expect over the next half century, nor the interest payments on our bloated national debt.

By focusing on Social Security, Lind misses the forest for the tree. Entitlement spending in all its forms and guises, not just Social Security, is unsustainable. Boomergeddon, the age wave apocalypse, is coming.

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Another Tick Closer to Fiscal Doomsday

Back in the good old days -- like yesterday -- you could reassure yourself that the Social Security trust fund would continue racking up surpluses until the year 2017, and wouldn't run out of reserves until 2041. Thus, if you were 56 years old like I am, you could count on drawing full benefits until you turned 88 years old, at which point, if you were lucky, you'd be too senile to notice that the money flowing into the system would cover a payout of only 75% of what you'd been getting before.

Today is a different story. The Associated Press reports that, thanks to the recession, the Social Security trustees are publishing a somewhat bleaker forecast. Social Security revenues are projected to tip from surplus to deficit one year earlier, 2016, than previously estimated, and the trust fund will run out of money four years earlier, in 2037.

Thus, the possibility exists that I'll be only 84 years old when fiscal Doomsday arrives, in which case my brain may still be capable enough of cutting through the fog of senescence to comprehend my plight. On the other hand, my wife, who is seven years younger than me, will be only 77. As her mind tends to be more focused than mine, our state of wretchedness will be all too clear to her.

That's assuming, of course, that we're still alive. There's no way of knowing what the condition of our health care system will be like then. Medicare Part A, which pays hospital bills, is already running a deficit, and the trust fund will be depleted by 2017. That's only eight years away. Thus, by the time roughly half of the nation's 78 million Baby Boomers reach traditional retirement age, Medicare could have crashed and burned already.

Welcome to Boomergeddon, the age wave apocalypse.