Here's some more news to brighten your day: An increasing number of malls are going out of business, putting financial pressure on the retailers and mall developers that make a living from them, and creating another headache for the banks that finance them. Besides suffering from a massive hangover from excess borrowing, the U.S. soon will feel the effects of building projects in the wrong locations.
In the 12 months ended March 31, reports the Wall Street Journal, U.S. malls collectively logged a 6.5% decline in tenant same-store sales. That's a direct outgrowth of consumers retrenching from their decades-long binge of mass overconsumption. Retail sales are down not only because consumer credit is tightening but because millions of Americans have awoken to the fact that they carry way too much debt and have saved too little for retirement. It will take years for retail spending to return to 2008 levels.
But the awfulness doesn't stop there. The decline in retail sales is hurting big retailers, prompting Stardard & Poor's to downgrade credit ratings on department store companies like Macy's and Sears. General Growth Properties, a Real Estate Investment Trust owning more than 200 malls, filed for bankrtupcy protection last month. Based on the rule of thumb that malls must generate $250 per square foot or more to survive, the WSJ has concluded that 84 of the 1,032 malls in the Green Street database are in danger of failing.
What the Journal article doesn't explore is the location of those malls. I would hypothesize that the vast majority are located on the development fringe of metropolitan areas -- the farthest outposts of "suburban sprawl" (an imprecise term that I hate using) developed in the era of cheap gasoline, long commutes and massive speculative building of residential real estate. The real estate bubble has burst, however, and the glut of unsold houses is worst in outlying areas. Many developers will find that not only are consumers spending less, but the markets their malls were built to serve will never materialize. Wealth destruction on such a massive scale is a tragedy.
The story gets worse. Malls are extremely difficult to repurpose. Owners will find it difficult to adapt them to an alternate use. And timing is running out. The five-year financing for many developers will expire in a year or two, and developers will have to refinance. It's only a matter of time before we see a slew of developer bankruptcies -- and another massive wave of bad loans reported by banks. It's not clear to me if the Obama administration's bank "stress tests" took the impending tidal wave of commercial real estate defaults, but I wouldn't be surprised if the issue was swept under the rug.
Burt P. Flickinger III with Strategic Resource Group, a research firm, put it this way to the Journal: "The shopper-center bankrtuptcies and the REIT bankruptcies are the ticking time bomb that people aren't talking about."
Sadly, Boomergeddonites, there is more bad economic news, more banking hysteria, and more pressure for government bail-outs to come. The age wave apocalypse may be running ahead of schedule.
(By the way, type in "empty mall" on YouTube, and you'll see dozens of video clips like the one above.)
.jpg)