Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Retire Early -- Get Yours While You Can

Just when I thought things couldn't get any worse... they got worse. Forget the effluvia that pass for headlines coming out of Wall Street and the White House. We track broad social and economic trends here at Boomergeddon, and one key indicator -- the age at which Americans retire -- has turned negative. In the process, the American people proved me naive. Worse, the churlish dogs proved me wrong! How dare they?

Here's the background: One of the few shreds of good cheer that I could extract from the misery of the past year is what seemed to be the changing attitude of the American people. (See my heart-rendingly misguided post of two days ago.) The politicians may be failing us, I thought, but the sturdy stock from the heartland would set things right. Americans had responded in survey after survey that they intended to spend less, pay down debt, save more and work longer before retiring. The evidence pointed to a fundamental shift in values -- a rejection of the something-for-nothing attitude responsible for the mess we're in -- that would outlast the economic downturn.

Now comes the Los Angeles Times with the news that far from delaying retirement, Baby Boomers are retiring earlier than ever! Since the beginning of the fiscal year Oct. 1, Social Security enrollments have been running 25% ahead of last year, compared to the 15% that had been forecast. That alarming data point comes from Stephen C. Goss, chief actuary for the Social Security Administration. (Hat tip to reader Groveton for alerting me to the story.)

As the L.A. Times article dryly notes: "The numbers upend expectations that older Americans who sustained financial losses in the recession would work longer to rebuild their nest eggs. In a December poll sponsored by CareerBuilder, 60% of workers older than 60 said they planned to postpone retirement."

Goss suggests that many of the enrollees are laid-off workers grasping for any source of income they can find. That explanation sounds plausible, and it may well be true. But it may not be the whole story.

Here's what really scares me: What if Boomers are retiring early because they don't trust the system? Dr. Helen Smith raises the possibility in her Dr. Helen blog: "My guess is that anyone close to early retirement figures it's now or never, given the possibility that Social Security benefits will be cut down or dry up in the near future."

The Social Security Administration says it has enough money in the till to last until 2037. But rational people will act on that knowledge only if they believe the retirement safety net won't combust between now and then. We may be witnessing an erosion of confidence on the part of everyday Americans that parallels the increasing disquiet in the financial world with America the Profligate.

1 comment:

  1. an interesting development.

    and a question:

    Let's say that in the future that Social Security decides that they must cut benefits.

    Here's the question.


    Would they cut benefits on future retirees or existing retirees or both?

    or... will social security move to a different structure all together like a guaranteed minimum plan with an optional defined contribution plan...supplemental?

    be forewarned - this is a tricky question but the basic premise is - if the Feds can make virtually any transaction an unfathomable mess for the average citizen.. why not use that approach on future social security benefits?

    ha ha ha

    ReplyDelete