Showing posts with label Reinventing retirement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reinventing retirement. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Retire Early -- Get Yours While You Can

Just when I thought things couldn't get any worse... they got worse. Forget the effluvia that pass for headlines coming out of Wall Street and the White House. We track broad social and economic trends here at Boomergeddon, and one key indicator -- the age at which Americans retire -- has turned negative. In the process, the American people proved me naive. Worse, the churlish dogs proved me wrong! How dare they?

Here's the background: One of the few shreds of good cheer that I could extract from the misery of the past year is what seemed to be the changing attitude of the American people. (See my heart-rendingly misguided post of two days ago.) The politicians may be failing us, I thought, but the sturdy stock from the heartland would set things right. Americans had responded in survey after survey that they intended to spend less, pay down debt, save more and work longer before retiring. The evidence pointed to a fundamental shift in values -- a rejection of the something-for-nothing attitude responsible for the mess we're in -- that would outlast the economic downturn.

Now comes the Los Angeles Times with the news that far from delaying retirement, Baby Boomers are retiring earlier than ever! Since the beginning of the fiscal year Oct. 1, Social Security enrollments have been running 25% ahead of last year, compared to the 15% that had been forecast. That alarming data point comes from Stephen C. Goss, chief actuary for the Social Security Administration. (Hat tip to reader Groveton for alerting me to the story.)

As the L.A. Times article dryly notes: "The numbers upend expectations that older Americans who sustained financial losses in the recession would work longer to rebuild their nest eggs. In a December poll sponsored by CareerBuilder, 60% of workers older than 60 said they planned to postpone retirement."

Goss suggests that many of the enrollees are laid-off workers grasping for any source of income they can find. That explanation sounds plausible, and it may well be true. But it may not be the whole story.

Here's what really scares me: What if Boomers are retiring early because they don't trust the system? Dr. Helen Smith raises the possibility in her Dr. Helen blog: "My guess is that anyone close to early retirement figures it's now or never, given the possibility that Social Security benefits will be cut down or dry up in the near future."

The Social Security Administration says it has enough money in the till to last until 2037. But rational people will act on that knowledge only if they believe the retirement safety net won't combust between now and then. We may be witnessing an erosion of confidence on the part of everyday Americans that parallels the increasing disquiet in the financial world with America the Profligate.

Saturday, May 23, 2009

A Little Work Never Hurt Anyone

It's a good thing the American people have more common sense than their political leaders do. If the United States dodges Boomergeddon, the age wave apocalypse, we will have the citizenry to thank, not the panderers in Washington, D.C. Repeated opinion surveys have shown that Americans are changing their expectations about retirement. For the first time in more than 100 years, it's possible that Americans, on average, will start retiring later in life, not earlier. That could ease the excruciating financial pressure on the nation's old-age entitlement programs.

According to "Retirement at the Tipping Point," a report issued by the Age Wave consulting firm, pre-retirees say they will need to postpone their retirement by 4.2 years on average. Baby Boomers, who are closest to retirement, figure on delaying it by 3.6 years, Gen Xers and Millennials (Gen Ys) by as much as five years.

As the table below, taken from the Age Wave study, shows, the trend toward earlier retirement reached a plateau in the 1980s that has remain largely fixed for 25 years. Thanks to longer life expectancies, though, Americans are spending more years in retirement.


If you think about it, the social trends of (a) living longer and (b) retiring earlier are difficult to sustain. The Age Wave study discusses a concept called the "work-to-retirement" ratio, the number of years an average American works expressed as a ratio of the number of years they spend in retirement.

A century ago, when the average retirement age was 74 and life expectancies were far shorter than today, retirements tended to be short. Really short. On average, Americans spent 54 years working for every year they spent in retirement. By 1950 that ratio had improved considerably: On average, Americans spent 6.3 years working for every year they spent in retirement. That ratio has continued to improve, reaching the point in 2005 when Americans spent 2.2 years working for every year in retirement.

Let's express that another way: Americans are spending one third of their adult (post-education) years in retirement.

Americans are now realizing that expectations for so much leisure time are unrealistic. One reason people are having such trouble saving sufficient sums for retirement is that they aren't working long enough. (Remember, much of wealth accumulation comes from the simple power of compound interest.) Similarly, one reason Social Security and Medicare will run out of money is that the number of Americans working and paying into the system will be too small to support the number of retirees drawing benefits.

Many politicians and pundits persist in peddling the fantasy that we can continue expanding our entitlements without bankrupting the country. The American people have more sense: They know they have to work longer. Now, let's see if they actually do.

Postscript: European opinion seems to be going in the wrong direction. Governing elites understand the fiscal dilemma posed by their nations' rich retirement programs, but the people are less than enthusiastic about the idea of delaying retirement. Indeed, a majority of citizens in Spain (67%), Italy (60%), France (57%), Greece (57%) and Austria (54%) say they want to retire earlier, according to a recent French survey. Large minorities in northern Europe want the same thing.

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

New Attitude

A couple of months ago, I was vacationing with my family at the Club Med in Cancun when I got to know an affable Frenchman, Michel, a former school teacher who now was pursuing the good life. He maintained a home in Paris and a pied a terre on the Mediterranean coast, and he took two long (by American standards) vacations every year. He'd visited most of the Club Meds between the Maldives and the Turks & Caicos islands.

Although Michel was about my age, give or take a year, he was retired already. I figure I'll be working full time at least 10 more years, until I'm 66 or 67, and even then, I'll likely work on and off on projects of my choosing. It's my sense that Michel and I are fairly representative of the Baby Boomer generations of our respective countries. We have very different expectations about what retirement means and of the obligation of the state to meet those expectations.

Here in America, the ambition of the Silent Generation (those born between 1926 and 1945) was very much like that of the Europeans -- to retire as early as possible with enough money to travel the world, have a house on the beach, sail boats, play golf or pursue their personal interests. To both the Europeans and the Silent Gens, retirement marked a dramatic life transition: a move from the world of work to the world of leisure.

There is widespread recognition in both Europe and the U.S. that the dream is unaffordable. Yet it has been difficult both here and there to reform the pension and health care systems. Working through their lobby, the AARP, the Silent Gens in the U.S. have stridently opposed efforts to dial back their retirement privileges. Indeed, during the Bush administration, they succeeded in winning an expansion of the Medicare program that will cost trillions of dollars over the next half century.

But the Baby Boomers may be a different story. While Boomers still look to government for Social Security and health care benefits in their old age -- they've paid into the system, by George, and they want to get something out of it -- they aren't dogmatic about retiring early. Boomers, as a generation, have found meaning in life largely through their work. Their identities are tied up in their jobs. Surveys have found that a majority of Boomers see work as a way to stay mentally engaged, remain connected to other people and otherwise retain their vitality.

Boomers are redefining the work/retirement transition from an all-or-nothing proposition to an opportunity to re-set the work-life balance. In a survey conducted by the Age Wave consulting firm, "Retirement at the Tipping Point," only 30% of Boomers said they saw themselves never working again. Forty-three percent said they expected to go back and forth between periods of work and leisure, while 22% said they probably would work part time. Many Boomers fantasize about starting a new business, often based around a personal interest, or about applying their skills for a worthy cause.

This new Boomer attitude is a very good thing. For starters, Boomers have failed miserably as a generation to save for their retirement. They'll need the money. What I find most reassuring, though, is that they aren't looking to the Big Daddy in Washington, D.C. to bail them out. Americans know they screwed up by failing to save. They also suspect that Big Daddy may not be able to afford to maintain Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security at current levels in face of the retirement tsunami.

Boomers will have to save more (which means spending less) and they'll have to work longer, if they want to enjoy a secure and comfortable lifestyle in their old age. When the federal government faces insolvency 20 or 30 years from now, Boomers will have no choice but to fall back upon their own resources. They had better start preparing now. They appear to be doing so.