Showing posts with label Entitlements Crisis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Entitlements Crisis. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Retire Early -- Get Yours While You Can

Just when I thought things couldn't get any worse... they got worse. Forget the effluvia that pass for headlines coming out of Wall Street and the White House. We track broad social and economic trends here at Boomergeddon, and one key indicator -- the age at which Americans retire -- has turned negative. In the process, the American people proved me naive. Worse, the churlish dogs proved me wrong! How dare they?

Here's the background: One of the few shreds of good cheer that I could extract from the misery of the past year is what seemed to be the changing attitude of the American people. (See my heart-rendingly misguided post of two days ago.) The politicians may be failing us, I thought, but the sturdy stock from the heartland would set things right. Americans had responded in survey after survey that they intended to spend less, pay down debt, save more and work longer before retiring. The evidence pointed to a fundamental shift in values -- a rejection of the something-for-nothing attitude responsible for the mess we're in -- that would outlast the economic downturn.

Now comes the Los Angeles Times with the news that far from delaying retirement, Baby Boomers are retiring earlier than ever! Since the beginning of the fiscal year Oct. 1, Social Security enrollments have been running 25% ahead of last year, compared to the 15% that had been forecast. That alarming data point comes from Stephen C. Goss, chief actuary for the Social Security Administration. (Hat tip to reader Groveton for alerting me to the story.)

As the L.A. Times article dryly notes: "The numbers upend expectations that older Americans who sustained financial losses in the recession would work longer to rebuild their nest eggs. In a December poll sponsored by CareerBuilder, 60% of workers older than 60 said they planned to postpone retirement."

Goss suggests that many of the enrollees are laid-off workers grasping for any source of income they can find. That explanation sounds plausible, and it may well be true. But it may not be the whole story.

Here's what really scares me: What if Boomers are retiring early because they don't trust the system? Dr. Helen Smith raises the possibility in her Dr. Helen blog: "My guess is that anyone close to early retirement figures it's now or never, given the possibility that Social Security benefits will be cut down or dry up in the near future."

The Social Security Administration says it has enough money in the till to last until 2037. But rational people will act on that knowledge only if they believe the retirement safety net won't combust between now and then. We may be witnessing an erosion of confidence on the part of everyday Americans that parallels the increasing disquiet in the financial world with America the Profligate.

Friday, May 15, 2009

Can the Obama Administration Reform the Unreformable?

President Barack Obama has vowed to put the United States on a sustainable fiscal path, and Peter Orszag, his director of Management and Budget has an idea of how to do it: Bring health care costs under control.

Medicare and Medicaid expenditures, if left to increase unchecked, could increase from 5% of the Gross Domestic Product today to 20% by 2050, he wrote in a Wall Street Journal op-ed yesterday. "Over the long run, the deficit impact of every other fiscal policy variable is swamped by the impact of health-care costs. ... The good news is that there appear to be significant opportunities to reduce health-care costs over time without impairing the quality of care or outcomes."

Health care costs vary widely across different regions of the country, and even between hospitals and physicians within regions, he argues, following the thinking of Princeton health care economist Uwe Reinhardt. Yet there is little difference in the quality of the outcome. Quoting Reinhardt, he writes: "How can it be that the 'best medical care in the world' costs twice as much as 'the best medical care in the world?'"

By moving the nation toward proven best practices adopted by lower-cost areas and hospitals, suggests Orzsag, it may be possible to reduce health care expenditures by 30% -- or about $700 billion a year -- without compromising quality. Even if those efficiencies are achieved over decades, it should be possible to hold the Medicare/Medicaid share of the GDP to only 10% of the economy.

And how does he propose to tame health care?
There are four key steps: 1) health information technology, because we can't improve what we don't measure; 2) more research into what works and what doesn't, so doctors don't recommend treatments that don't improve health; 3) prevention and wellness, so that people do the things that keep them healthy and avoid costs associated with health risks such as smoking and obesity; and 4) changes in financial incentives for providers so that they are incentivized rather than penalized for delivering high-quality care.
In the abstract, there are all excellent ideas. Indeed, they are so excellent that health care analysts have been talking about them for years. The question we must ask is, why haven't they been implemented already? What is it about the political economy of health care in the United States stymies efforts to rationalize the system?

I don't have a complete answer, and if I did, it would be too long for this blog post. But let me suggest that the U.S. health care system is dysfunctional because of the intrusive reach of government at both the federal and state levels. I will just touch upon some of the highlights:
  • De facto price controls. Medicare and Medicaid reimburse hospitals and doctors on the basis of customary and traditional experience, not supply and demand. Moreover, they consistently pay less than the market price. The result is supply shortages in critical areas such as primary care. Primary care physicians are retiring in droves or retreating into lucrative concierge medicine practices, creating acute shortages of the front-line physicians required to provide the "prevention and wellness" that Orszag talks about.

  • Certificates of Public Need (COPN). Many if not most states regulate the ability of health care providers to build new facilities, on the grounds that new facilities add to the cost structure that insurers must reimburse. But COPN protects hospitals from competition -- not only from other hospitals but from surgery centers and other providers that specialize in procedures they can perform more productively and with superior patient outcomes.
  • Health care guilds. Much like a Medieval guild or a 20th century craft union, the health care industry is divided into occupational categories. Each is guarded by professional associations that lobby in state legislatures to set educational standards and protect their prerogatives vis a vis other occupations. The restrictions limit labor flexibility in the health care workplace and is deliterious to productivity.
  • Mandated benefits. The health care professions also lobby state legislators to require insurance carriers to provide certain types of health benefits. Mandates hamper the ability of carriers to provide affordable, bargain-basement health policies, contributing directly to the increase in the number of uninsured Americans.

The Obama administration has some good ideas for controlling runaway health care costs -- especially investing in Information Technology to bring the industry up to national standards. But color me skeptical. Not only will Orsag run into the usual buzz-saw of entrenched special interests and craven politicians in Congress, the Obamoids will find their ideas far more difficult to implement in the marketplace than they can imagine. If "comprehensive" health care reform is limited to the items that Orszag describes, it won't be very comprehensive at all.

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Apocalypse Denier

There is no entitlements crisis, writes Salon.com contributor Michael Lind in "Let's cut Social Security to pay for banker bailouts!" It's a scare ginned up by an "anti-Social Security lobby" consisting of "libertarian zealots, Jeffersonian conservatives, center-right Democrats and bankers and brokers who would like to earn fees or commissions from the diversion of Social Security payroll taxes into IRAs."

Lind concedes that health care costs are a legitimate problem, but he manages to sweep that issue under the rug by focusing on the supposed non-problem of Social Security. One point in particular struck me because it had the veneer of plausibility:

The anti-Social Security lobby always presents the "unfunded liabilities" of "entitlements" in scary dollar terms, rather than as percentage points of GDP. Here's why: Over the next 75 years, the Social Security shortfall at most hovers around 1 percent of total U.S. GDP over that same period. Yes, that's right -- around a whopping 1 percent of U.S. GDP. And that is only in the unlikely event that some combination of growth, taxes and benefit cuts do not eliminate the shortfall in the future.
Fair enough. Let's take a closer look at the numbers. The chart below shows total projected entitlement deficits as a percentage of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). I can assure readers that this does not come from libertarian zealots or anyone of that stripe. I took it from the just published "Summary of the 2009 Annual Reports" of the Social Security and Medicare boards of trustees. It was published under the names of four people, including three Obama appointees -- Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, Labor Secretary Hilda Solis, and Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius. Presumably, they are not party to any anti-Social Security cabal.

The blue on the bars represents revenue shortfalls for the Old-Age and Disability and Survivors Insurance (OASDI) trust fund, better known as the Social Security trust fund. Just as Lind says, the deficit never exceeds one percent of the GDP through the year 2083.

Of course, Social Security represents the most actuarially sound part of America's retirement safety net. It's the smallest part of the entitlement crisis. The red in the chart represents the projected revenue shortfall for Medicare Part A, also called HI, which covers payments to hospitals. The deficit in that program is growing rapidly, and will account for nearly 4% of the economy by 2083. That's the funding shortfall, mind you, not the total cost of the program. By way of comparison, the entire U.S. budget deficit in 2004, the bottom of the last business cycle, was 3.53% of GDP.

The green in the chart depicts SMI, or Medicare Parts B and D, which pay for physicians and drugs. Those don't have a trust fund. They generate some revenue from enrollees, but the bulk is paid out of the U.S. general fund. That deficit is roughly equal to the other two programs combined.

But that's not the end of the story. This chart doesn't touch upon the ramped up Medicaid expenditures we can expect over the next half century, nor the interest payments on our bloated national debt.

By focusing on Social Security, Lind misses the forest for the tree. Entitlement spending in all its forms and guises, not just Social Security, is unsustainable. Boomergeddon, the age wave apocalypse, is coming.

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Another Tick Closer to Fiscal Doomsday

Back in the good old days -- like yesterday -- you could reassure yourself that the Social Security trust fund would continue racking up surpluses until the year 2017, and wouldn't run out of reserves until 2041. Thus, if you were 56 years old like I am, you could count on drawing full benefits until you turned 88 years old, at which point, if you were lucky, you'd be too senile to notice that the money flowing into the system would cover a payout of only 75% of what you'd been getting before.

Today is a different story. The Associated Press reports that, thanks to the recession, the Social Security trustees are publishing a somewhat bleaker forecast. Social Security revenues are projected to tip from surplus to deficit one year earlier, 2016, than previously estimated, and the trust fund will run out of money four years earlier, in 2037.

Thus, the possibility exists that I'll be only 84 years old when fiscal Doomsday arrives, in which case my brain may still be capable enough of cutting through the fog of senescence to comprehend my plight. On the other hand, my wife, who is seven years younger than me, will be only 77. As her mind tends to be more focused than mine, our state of wretchedness will be all too clear to her.

That's assuming, of course, that we're still alive. There's no way of knowing what the condition of our health care system will be like then. Medicare Part A, which pays hospital bills, is already running a deficit, and the trust fund will be depleted by 2017. That's only eight years away. Thus, by the time roughly half of the nation's 78 million Baby Boomers reach traditional retirement age, Medicare could have crashed and burned already.

Welcome to Boomergeddon, the age wave apocalypse.