Monday, May 25, 2009

Up to the Neck in Debt

Money Magazine publishes a "Best Places to Retire" ranking of American MSAs (Metropolitan Statistical Areas) that factors in such considerations as affordable housing, life expectancy and availability of real estate on the water. I suppose the list will prove useful to someone with a five- or 10-year time horizon but the guidance is suitable only to those who think the future will be like today -- only more so. If you believe, like I do, that the United States faces an age wave apocalypse, you expect the country to experience major discontinuities that will render current retirement nostrums null and void.

If the federal government becomes insolvent, the criteria for "best places to retire" will change drastically. Among other things, people will look for state and local governments that are fiscally sound enough to provide basic government services -- perhaps even to pick up some of the functions that the federal government will be compelled to abandon.

I made much the same point last Thursday, when I asked the question, "Who will pick up the pieces?" The example of California, which is bidding to become the next federal bail-out recipient, does not inspire confidence. To provide readers a gauge of the states' fiscal health, I reproduced a ranking of state bond ratings. But reader Peter Galuszka reminded me that the track record in recent years of the rating agencies, including Standard & Poor's, hardly inspires confidence in their judgment.

Fair enough. The list at right, modified from data compiled by the Tax Foundation (and passed along by alert reader Larry Gross) contains two important data points for each of the 50 states: indebtedness per capita, and state debt as a percentage of the Gross Domestic Product. For purposes of comparison, remember that the per-capita debt of the United States stood at 44% last year and is projected to reach 77% by 2013.

(Click on image for more legible version.)

It is interesting to note that some states with a small-government reputation -- Montana, New Hampshire and South Carolina -- rank high in indebtedness. Texas and Tennessee, by this criterion, are looking golden. Conversely, the debt burden of California, today's poster child of fiscal woe, is slightly lower than the national average. Presumably, the Golden State's troubles have causes other than excessive borrowing. Therefore, be warned: A favorable, low-indebtedness ranking on this list is no guarantee of future solvency.

But it's safe to say this: All other things being equal, states with low levels of indebtedness have more financial flexibility to face the uncertainties of the future than those that are in hock up to their necks. Massachusetts -- more than $10,500 in debt and a debt-to-GDP ratio of 19.8% two years ago -- is not a state that I would count on to provide old-age services a decade or two from now.

9 comments:

  1. I keep liking my new state (Texas) better and better all the time.

    ReplyDelete
  2. U.S. Average 3,124 - 7.0%

    Virginia 2,564 - 5.2% AAA

    California 3,151 - 6.5% A1

    Mass 10,546 - 19.8% AA2

    Any way you cut it.. Massachusetts has one heck of a lot of debt and by this laymans logic .. ought to be in much worse shape than California.

    Surely there must be some other metrics that better illustrate California's plight .. cuz these are not doing it for me.

    ReplyDelete
  3. at $1,100 dollars per capita... Texas is better than Virginia...

    this is a job for GrovetonMan.

    The thing that impresses me is the very diverse nature of the debt held by the various states.

    One would presume (perhaps wrongly) that the states are all building similar equivalent infrastructure but clearly this is not the case.

    I say infrastructure rather than services because debt is usually not obtainable (nor sustainable) to pay for operational expenses.

    With almost 20K per capita debt.. what the heck did Mass build that other states did not?

    Was it the Big Dig?

    Did they invest in many more schools ( and that explains why they are #1 in education ratings?)

    Of course... one of the educational rating agencies is part of Standard and Poors also.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. A somewhat better rendition of the above:

    Texas / Texans fiscal position -- Households, Agencies, Enterprises and Institutions -- have three pillars:

    Revenue from buning thru Natural Capital, in-state and world-wide

    Low Outlay due to not funding general welfare -- education, safety, etc.

    Widening the Wealth Gap by failure to fairly allocate costs

    Folks at the top of the Ziggurat tend to like these approachs

    Folks at the bottom? Not so much!!

    Smoke, mirrors, hubris and jingoism only go so far and so long in a democracy.

    EMR

    ReplyDelete
  6. how does EMR's view deal with this:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_external_debt

    or perhaps more to the point - what level of per capita debt is optimal or is any/all debt verboten?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Larry said:

    "how does EMR's view deal with this:

    "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_external_debt

    "or perhaps more to the point - what level of per capita debt is optimal or is any/all debt verboten?"

    Interesting table but EMR has no idea what question Larry is asking. Sometimes he seems to have his random questions generator in overdrive.

    One observation: The only place outside the US of A where EMR has had substantial property interests had only $36 mil in External Debt and that was only only 4.2 percent of GDP.

    So if EMR decides to be an expat to escape the Retirement Crisis he knows where he will go.

    EMR

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. And speaking of Texas:

    This week WaPo had a nice item "Better Life beckons in Africa: U.S. Downturn Drives Immigrant Professionals Back Home. Featured James Odhimbo a truck driver in Texas.

    He moved from Kenya to Texas to get ahead in the world but has moved back to Kisumu, Kenya where he has better opportunities and less stree.

    What did EMR say about those at the bottom of the Ziggurat in Texas?

    EMR

    ReplyDelete